An Integrated Criticality Safety Approach for Heterogeneously Loaded Spent Nuclear Fuel Casks
Date Issued
May 2026
Author(s)
Clarity, Justin Brendan
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Steven Skutnik
Additional Advisor(s)
William Marshall
Ivan Maldonado
Sandra Bogetic
Abstract
Criticality analysis that credits the effects of fuel depletion for spent nuclear fuel (SNF) systems or burnup credit (BUC) has been instrumental in expanding the capacity of systems used for transportation. Typical approaches to BUC assume a uniform loading of fuel with a single set of fuel characteristics. All SNF loaded in the casks must meet the limits set by this analysis. This work investigates the application of burnup credit methods to SNF casks while crediting the actual fuel inventory, referred to as as-loaded BUC. Performing BUC analysis while crediting the as-loaded contents requires adaption of the traditional techniques for accounting for uncertainties in the contents and the computational methods used to perform the analysis. Significant components of this work are centered around adapting the guidance issued in Interim Staff Guidance 8, Revision 3 (ISG-8, Rev. 3) for the heterogeneous loadings.
This work performs BUC calculations for a series of 38 example casks using the underlying methods that were used to implement methods to account for cask reactivity and the uncertainties in the predicted composition of the SNF and the prediction of reactivity by the criticality code. The uncertainties in cask reactivity due to the prediction of the SNF composition are estimated using a Monte Carlo uncertainty sampling method and a sensitivity-based method. The criticality code validation is accomplished using a sensitivity/uncertainty method to select critical experiments which are then processed into a bias and bias uncertainty. The cask reactivity, nuclide composition uncertainties and criticality code uncertainties are then combined to demonstrate the subcriticality of the example casks for transportation and disposal scenarios. Based on this work it is concluded that it is possible to use as-loaded BUC to demonstrate the subcriticality of the 38 systems. Additional recommendations are also provided for enhancing the experimental data and computational methods to remove additional conservatism from the methods used here.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Nuclear Engineering
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
CLARITY-PRIMARY-2026.pdf
Size
5.66 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
1134c8e28ee74faba13c9c4010895b08