VetMANE: Veterinarians' Motivations for Academic and Non-Academic Employment
Date Issued
May 2026
Author(s)
Carney, Kimberly Ann
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Jennifer Morrow
Additional Advisor(s)
India Lane
Robert Kelchen
Karen Boyd
Abstract
Faculty shortages in higher education and veterinary medicine pose increasing challenges to public and animal health. This dissertation explores motivations, organizational conditions, and career evaluations that shape veterinarians’ decisions to enter, remain, avoid or leave academia through a three-part, mixed-methods investigation. It introduces the Circumstances-Interpretation-Evaluation-Action (CIEA) framework, integrating career choice and job satisfaction theories to explain faculty career decision-making as dynamic and iterative.
The first article presents a systematic review of empirical studies (2020–2024) on faculty recruitment, persistence, and turnover intention across higher education. Findings identify job demands, resources, organizational climate, and personal factors influential in job satisfaction and turnover intention. The literature lacks a unified explanatory model, treating predictors as static determinants rather than evolving influences.
The second article reports results from the VetMANE national survey of U.S. veterinarians, comparing those never in academia, former faculty, and current faculty. Anticipated inadequacy of compensation, bureaucracy, and workload expectations deterred entry to academia. Academic role models and advanced training pathways were positively associated with academic careers. Factors associated with persistence differed from those inspiring entry. Among current faculty intent to leave was associated with manageability of workload, leadership quality, institutional culture and climate, and burnout indicators. Preparedness for academic roles influenced early experiences but was not associated with intent to leave. While salary functioned primarily as a barrier to entry, those in faculty noted total compensation packages and overall worklife alignment, not simply salary, as a retention factor.
The third article explores experiences of second-career academics (SCAs), veterinarians who transitioned into academia after significant clinical experience, via qualitative interviews using interpretive description. Seven analytic domains highlighted the importance of career timing, professional and personal identity, autonomy, leadership, and intentional onboarding. Entry often occurred through invitation and exposure rather than deliberate aspiration. Persistence reflected alignment of personal values, life circumstances, and institutional fit.
The synthesis integrates findings through the CIEA framework, demonstrating how career decisions emerge through ongoing interpretation and evaluation of demands, resources, identity and circumstances. This research offers a recursive model of career decision and actionable recommendations for strengthening recruitment and retention in veterinary colleges and other professional fields.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Higher Education Administration
Embargo Date
May 1, 2032