What I Know: How Conceptualizations of Knowledge Influence Sense of Belonging Among Black, Brown, and Indigenous Women of Color in PhD Programs
Date Issued
May 2026
Author(s)
The University of Tennessee
Advisor(s)
Frances K. Harper
Additional Advisor(s)
David Bowers
Leia K. Cain
Francheska D. Starks
Abstract
The purpose of this study is to explore how conceptualizations of knowledge in academia influence sense of belonging among Black, Brown, Indigenous, and other Women of Color (BBIWOC) during their doctoral studies. To address the purpose, I began with post-structural philosophy and utilized post-qualitative inquiry. Data collection included autoethnography, individual interviews, and focus groups. Data analysis included collage and writing as inquiry. Findings are represented through social fiction. Participants perceive knowledge in nuanced ways that delineate academic knowledge and learning from wisdom and embodied knowledge. Though intertwined, each conceptualization of knowledge relates to sense of belonging in a different way. For example, one participant is quoted as saying, “how do I quote my grandmother?” in the context of explaining that she feels like the knowledge she’s gained from her lived experiences are not valid or welcome in academic spaces such as classrooms. Alternatively, as a whole, participants expressed that they have learned how to produce the kind of content (i.e., knowledge) they know their professors are looking for when they complete assignments. However, in doing so, there is a sense that they are undermining feelings of belongingness towards their families and communities that exist outside of academia. A deeper understanding of how epistemology shapes BBIWOC scholars’ sense of belonging in higher education is a critical missing piece in efforts to diversify the professoriate. Because dominant understandings of epistemology are rooted in Eurocentric, male-dominant, and heteronormative perspectives, academia selectively legitimizes certain discourses, while undervaluing scholarship that centers historically and contemporarily marginalized perspectives This narrow scope perpetuates exclusion and limits the potential for knowledge production that serves the broader public good. Because BBIWOC scholars have different lived experiences than those who currently dominate higher education, they bring diverse knowledges and perspectives to ask questions and produce knowledge in areas that are otherwise left unattended. Expanding intellectual inquiry in education necessitates broadening our understanding of valid knowledge. By offering insights into how dominant conceptualizations and constructions of knowledge shape the doctoral experiences of BBIWOC scholars, this study confronts current issues of knowledge hegemony.
Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Cultural Studies in Educational Foundations
File(s)![Thumbnail Image]()
![Thumbnail Image]()
Name
1777468391620-B._Parker_2026_Dissertation_Accessibility_Report_4-29.pdf
Size
159.74 KB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
4df88dadd702a405fed8433af3b55c71
Name
PARKER-PRIMARY-2026.pdf
Size
1.94 MB
Format
Adobe PDF
Checksum (MD5)
f6a5187019bfb70cd473108825ca835c