Public choice : transportation preferences of community decision makers and transportation consumers
The purpose of this study was to learn more about the expression of community decision makers' self-interest, public interest, and consumer interest concerns through an analysis of decision makers' policy preferences and consumers' travel behavior and attitudes. Decision makers' interests are central to the question of whether urban communities are capable of dealing effectively with transportation problems. The policy participation of automobile-dependent consumers is essential if decision makers are to determine effective policy solutions.
It was hypothesized that differences would exist in policy preferences related to public transportation improvement and expansion between decision makers affiliated with various political and bureaucratic organizations. The anticipated differences were based on the belief that decision makers express self-interest through policy preferences which do not conflict with organizational objectives and reelection aspirations. It was hypothesized further that a positive relationship would exist between decision makers' perceptions of transportation problems and decision makers' allocations of subsidy funds to transportation consumers with access to an automobile.
Data generated from surveys of decision makers' public transportation policy preferences and consumers' travel behavior and attitudes were used to test the hypotheses and determine whether the policy preferences of decision makers were consistent with the travel behavior and attitudes The sample consisted of 42 decision makers and 1,108 automobile-dependent consumers from the Jacksonville, Florida, urban area. Decision makers were assigned to one of four mutually exclusive groups based on organizational affiliation.
One-way analyses of variance indicated that there were e differences between decision-maker groups in the allocation of subsidy funds to consumers with access to automobiles and in the evaluations of public transportation performance. Results of Duncan's multiple range tests showed that the pattern of group responses was consistent with identified group interests. No group differences were observed for the allocation of funds for trip purposes, public transportation, specific public transportation services, and support for categories of revenue sources. Pearson product-moment correlation coefficients indicated that there were no relationships between decision makers' perceptions of transportation problems and decision makers' allocations of subsidy funds to transportation consumers with access to automobiles. Though differences were found between decision-maker groups which reflected organizational interests, in the aggregate the opinions of decision makers were for the most part consistent with the travel behavior and attitudes of consumers.
Thesis78b.M333.pdf
9.62 MB
Adobe PDF
27fdea9a496bd05b324bf716935af4e9