The prediction of counseling orientation preference from personality characteristics
Counseling preference has been demonstrated to have an effect on both the quality of the initial counseling session and the outcome of treatment. Higher ratings of counseling efficacy for the first session were the result when the interview was consistent with the client's preferred counseling style. In addition, the outcome was found to be significantly better for subjects receiving their preferred form of treatment when preferences were selected after subjects were exposed to explanations of several approaches. As a result of the findings on preference, the establishment of a method of preference based clientcounselor matching has been recommended. One such method involves the differentiation of preference groups based on personality characteristics which has been shown to be possible when a selection between two approaches is provided.
This study was undertaken to utilize a choice between three counseling orientations in order to distinguish between preference groups using personality characteristics. In addition, this study was designed to isolate the counseling approaches more effectively by controlling for extraneous variables, a limitation of most other preference research involving tapes or films. This was accomplished by employing the same counselor and client to demonstrate the approaches, thereby holding constant such factors as physical characteristics which have been shown to affect preference.
The preference was made after the subjects viewed video tapes of the three counseling orientations: Behavioral Counseling, Client- Centered Counseling, and Rational-Emotive Counseling. The subjects were 203 students enrolled in psychology courses in a community college. It was hypothesized that: : (1) Subjects choosing Client-Centered Counseling would be more internal, on the variable locus of control, than those choosing Rational-Emotive or Behavioral Counseling with the latter the more external; (2) Subjects in the Behavioral Counseling group would be more reserved followed by subjects in the Rational-Emotive group and finally those in the Client-Centered group as the more outgoing; (3) The Behavioral group would be more tough-minded and the Client-Centered group more tender-minded or sensitive with the Rational- Emotive group falling in between the other two groups; (4) The subjects choosing the Behavioral Counseling would be more group dependent as compared to those choosing the Rational-Emotive or Client-Centered Counseling, with those choosing the latter the most self-sufficient; and (5) The Client-Centered group would be the more relaxed followed by the Rational-Emotive group with the Behavioral group the most tense.
The results of the study failed to support the five hypotheses. There were only slight differences on the personality variables with few of them in the predicted direction, and the use of discriminant analysis did not yield significant results. The flat profiles that resulted for the three groups may be attributed to the use of a forced preference format in which subjects were grouped regardless of the strength of their preferences.
vi Qualitative responses concerning reasons for preference were sorted and categorized by graduate students. The qualitative groupings indicate that the subjects interpreted the same counselor behaviors differently as indicative of various degrees of such counselor variables as involvement, concern, and effectiveness. The development of a precounseling preference questionnaire was recommended based on the qualitative findings.
Thesis78b.H444.pdf
5.46 MB
Adobe PDF
716d60a3368accf065d0a28d2b4bcf35