Moderators of the job performance-job satisfaction relationship for research scientists
The primary purpose of this study was to evaluate the moderating influence of a variety of individual and job variables on the relationship between job performance and job satisfaction for a sample of research scientists. The widely discrepant results from previous studies investigating the performance-satisfaction relationship indicate that other factors may be acting as moderators.
Performance, satisfaction, and moderator score data were obtained from 103 scientists working in a research component of a large Federal a gen cy. Job satisfaction was measured with the Minnesota Satisfaction Questionnaire. Five measures of job performance were obtained: supervisory ratings, peer ratings, average accomplishment score, total publications, and overall performance.
Performance was found to be positively related to overall satisfaction (r = .36) and the relationship was found to be stronger for intrinsic satisfaction than extrinsic satisfaction. Twelve potential moderators were examined: organizational level, participation in decision-making, pressure-for-production, task characteristics, role clarity, role conflict, leader initiating structure, leader consideration, instrumentality, overall motivation, locus of control, and need for achievement. The variables were evaluated using several moderator detection techniques: moderator subgroup analysis, standard errors of estimate, moderated regression, and predictability analysis.
iii
iv
The results indicated that a positive performance-satisfaction relationship was facilitated by three individual characteristics--high motivation, internal rather than external control, and strong need for achievement--and four job characteristics--high organizational level, participation in decision-making, high level of task characteristics, and low level of leader initiating structure. However, the results also showed that some of these factors exerted overlapping, nonunique moderator influences. The findings were discussed in terms of possible causal relationships between job performance and job satisfaction.
Thesis78b.G698.pdf
7.11 MB
Adobe PDF
18d7071bc3d3413b76fcc963bd04364f