Mylai and the law : an analysis of how international law relates to the Mylai incident and its cover-up
The purpose of this study was to examine the legal controls pertaining to the events which occurred at Mylai during the Vietnam conflict. In this manner insight into the content of law and the difficulties associated with its implementation and enforcement could be gained.
In analyzing the international law of war as it relates to Mylai, the Geneva Convention Relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War, and the Geneva Convention Relative to the Protection of Civilians were of particular importance. However, because the implementation and enforcement of international law are dependent upon municipal law, it was also necessary to examine United States military law which incorporates the international law of war through Article l8 of the Uniform Code of Military Justice.
It was found that modern-day warfare has blurred the distinction between combatants and civilians and tends to diminish the effectiveness of the Geneva Conventions in situations like Mylai where the status of the inhabitants was uncertain. . While Article 5 of the Geneva Convention Relative to the Treatment of Prisoners of War, the most valid article of the Conventions, provides for a tribunal to determine the status of inhabitants in uncertain situations, it was not used at ilylai and the assault, murder, and rape of the inhabitants resulted in violations of the law of war.
It was also found that responsibility for the violations of the law of war at Mylai was limited. The procedure for discovering
iii
iv violations is inherently faulty; the responsibility of the military commander to report violations of the law of war is in conflict with the theory of command responsibility by which a military commander may be held responsible for the acts of his subordinates. The cover-up of the Mylai incident accounts for the lapse of time between the commission of the violations and their investigation by Army officials. This made the discovery of evidence sufficient to formally charge those allegedly involved in the incident and its cover-up difficult to accomplish. Consequently, only six members of the military were court-martialed.
The court-martial was the only judicial forum used to enforce the international law of war. While its jurisdiction was properly constituted in the six cases evolving from the Mylai incident and its cover-up, the jurisdiction of the court-martial was uncertain in other circumstances related to Mylai and may account for its limited use. In enforcing the international law of war, the rights of individuals appear to be adequately protected in court-martial proceedings as is evidenced by the Calley case. However, the potential for command influence and other injustices do exist. In light of these potential difficulties and the limited use of the court-martial in dealing with alleged violations of the law of war at Mylai, alternative judicial forums were examined for the purpose of determining their effectiveness in enforcing the international law of war.
While the ability of the United States to formally change the content of the law of war is restricted, the United States has much control over its implementation and enforcement. The Mylai experience
has brought to light the danger of concentrating both the implementation and enforcement of the law of war in the military. While some changes in military procedures may help to implement the law of war more effectively, a change in the judicial forum may help to more effectively enforce the international law of war when violations do occur.
Thesis78b.G544.pdf
8.03 MB
Adobe PDF
ba667104d5f3e94d32e07811ae98a22b