Influence of race and sex of the accused on referral to and determination of competency to stand trial
Despite recent developments in the areas of minority and feminine rights, there has been little or no research on the effects of race or sex in forensic psychology. The present study was aimed at determining racial and sexual bias in the referral to and assessment of competency to stand trial. Demographic data covering a period of one year was gathered and analyzed to determine if there was evidence of bias in referral for and assessment of competency. Then, further evidence was gathered to evaluate whether there were discrepancies in the actual determination.
Subjects were four psychiatric residents who assessed thirty two persons for competency to stand trial after arrest for a felony. The setting was the Cincinnati Corrections Center and the Cincinnati Central Psychiatric Clinic, Court Clinic. After clinic staff had determined competency through use of a typical interview the subject was given the Competency Screening Test (CST) by a social worker. The Competency Screening Test was scored as an independent determiner of competency and compared to staff finding.
Results showed that, while there were no significant differences in referral rate and rate of incompetency findings by sex, there were significantly more black males referred for evaluation of competency to stand trial than would be expected by chance.
Finally, it was found that differences found between the subjects' evaluations and the Competency Screening Test results occurred only at a chance rate during a sixty day period.
Results were discussed in relationship to the possibility of racial bias being a factor in the discrepancies found. The findings of the present study suggest that bias within the system is a reflection of lack of communication. Alternative research questions and strategies are proposed.
Thesis78b.B682.pdf
2.1 MB
Adobe PDF
283b9b04e534ae15109def9d9bfb4688