Repository logo
Log In(current)
  1. Home
  2. Colleges & Schools
  3. Graduate School
  4. Doctoral Dissertations
  5. A comparative effects study of advertising puffery : an experiment
Details

A comparative effects study of advertising puffery : an experiment

Date Issued
December 1978
Author(s)
Bergh, Bruce Gerard Vanden
Advisor(s)
Jack B. Haskins
Additional Advisor(s)
Donald G. Hileman
Alan D. Fletcher
David W. Cravens
Permanent URI
https://trace.tennessee.edu/handle/20.500.14382/56940
Abstract

The purpose of this study was to experimentally test the relative effects of advertising puffery against the effects of realistic and understated advertising messages. Hypotheses were generated from assimilation-contrast theory which predicted the effect of manipulated discrepancies between a product as depicted in the treatment advertisements and the actual product on the following dependent variables: (l) The confirmation or disconfirmation of expectations, (2) change in message evaluations, (3) change in company evaluations, (4) change in message credibility, and (5) change in intent to purchase the advertised product. Subjects' initial expectations for the advertised product before experiencing the manipulated discrepancies were also measured.

A comparative treatments laboratory experiment was executed and data gathered from 8l students attending summer session classes at the University of Tennessee, Knoxville. Subjects were randomly assigned to each of three treatment groups. One group received a puffed newspaper advertisement, one a realistic newspaper ad, and one an understated newspaper ad for a ballpoint pen. After exposure to the treatment ads, each subject rated the pen depicted in the ad on a product rating scale. Subjects also evaluated the message and sponsoring company, rated the message's credibility, and indicated intent to purchase the pen. Message and company evaluations were measured with sets of semantic scales specially developed for each item evaluated. Message credibility ana intent to purchase were indicated on zero to 100 rating scales. After these procedures, all subjects were given a pen comparable in value to the one depicted in the realistic newspaper ad. Subjects were given a chance to inspect and use the pen. They were then asked if the pen was much better, better, about the same, worse, or much worse than the pen depicted in the newspaper ad. The product rating scale was administered again at this point in the experiment. Next, subjects were exposed to the treatment ads again and the message and company evaluations, message credibility rating, and intent to purchase measure repeated. Measures taken before exposure to the pen were subtracted from those taken afterward to generate change scores for each treatment group that were subsequently used in the analysis of the data.

Results reported appear to show that the use of puffery in advertising messages leads to several negative effects. The use of puffery seems to produce a discrepancy between expectations for product value and actual product value that leads to a negative change in: (1) consumer attitudes toward the message and sponsoring company, (2) message credibility, (3) and intent to purchase the product. Understatement of product value, on the other hand, seems to have a positive effect on these variables once people have used the advertised product.

The realistic message in this study produced an overall more negative effect than predicted, although this effect still fell between that produced by the puffed and understated messages.

Caution is suggested in interpreting these findings, as they only apply to the very special experimental situation created for this study and the limited population sampled. The possibility of confounding effects from the order in which treatments and measures were presented, and the repetition of measures is also duly noted.

Degree
Doctor of Philosophy
Major
Communication
File(s)
Thumbnail Image
Name

Thesis78b.B473.pdf

Size

5.48 MB

Format

Adobe PDF

Checksum (MD5)

9620d8f80c3adafbc1e402c7fc2ed46c


University Libraries

1015 Volunteer Boulevard
Knoxville, TN 37996
865-974-4351

Map & Directions
Donate to the Libraries
  • About
  • John C. Hodges Society
  • Speaking Volumes magazine
  • Outreach
  • Directory
  • Employment
  • Policies
  • Library Intranet
University of Tennessee power T logo

The University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Knoxville, Tennessee 37996
865-974-1000

Events
A-Z
Apply
Privacy
Map
Directory
Give to UT
Accessibility

Built with DSpace-CRIS software - Extension maintained and optimized by 4Science