The role of the plain folk in the Southern antebellum novel
As apologia for the Southern way of life and its peculiar institution, the typical antebellum novel is flawed by the artifices of romantic convention and open to justifiable criticism for its factitious and predictable plot, its high-handed hero and heroine, and its idyllic plantation setting. Beneath these contrivances, which glorify a South that never was, however, lies the true merit of the antebellum novel, its realistic depiction of the plain folk who are genuine representatives of the Old South. At the same time that the novel defends slavery by portraying idealized plantation life and pays tribute to Southern culture by creating incredibly chivalric gentlemen and genteel ladies, it serves as spokesman for American democracy in its graphic delineation of the stalwart yeomanry. Indeed, in the characterization of the plain folk--the soldiers, the farmers, the hunters, the artisans, the pioneer women--lies a value of the antebellum novel heretofore not properly acknowledged.
Although scholars such as Vernon L. Parrington and Jay B. Hubbell have taken passing note of the successful low characters in novels by major writers like William Gilmore Simms and John Pendleton Kennedy, for the most part, critics have seen the commoners merely as subordinates, and have not heeded the fullness of their characterization which lends vigor and plausibility to formulaic plots or acknowledged the pioneer strength, penetrating humor, and solid virtue of these people responsible for the exploration and settlement of the Old South. As a thorough study of works by Simms, Kennedy, William A. Caruthers, George and Beverley Tucker, and their contemporaries reveals, the plain folk are not only cast as realistic figures whose earthy speech and rude mannerisms parallel those of their historical counterparts, but within the confines of the four basic roles of scout, "natural noble," strong woman, and ambitious villain, they are also used to comment upon the evolving society of the Old South where, from the 1830's forward, the plantation was losing power and the gentleman was being displaced by his rough-hewn subordinates. The plain folk perform fundamental services in the novels as companions and foils to the aristocracy, as sources of humor, as representatives of basic morality, and as admirable, realistic figures emblematizing American democracy. Even the maleficent characters evince the sturdiness inherent in the common people.
Although authentic depiction of the Southern plain folk has long been credited to Southwestern humorists like Longstreet, Thompson, and G. W. Harris, who are noted for their vivid realizations of the common people at horse races, quilting-bees, corn-huskings, and gander-pullings, the antebellum novel must also be conceded as a lively source of genuine information about the plain folk. In the weddings, funerals, picnics, church meetings, and tavern brawls drawn in the novel is the Old South of reality where the common man's role was fundamental. Antebellum fiction may be justly reproached for its mechanical plots, labored style, and mincing aristocratic characters, but it is redeemed by the robust plain folk who impart life and zest into otherwise predictable tales of war and romance. One has only to look to Flannery O'Connor's tight-lipped decent women and sly misfits, to Eudora Welty's prideful family in Losing Battles, or to Faulkner's Boon Hogganbeck or even Flem Snopes to observe the continuing significance of the plain folk celebrated in the Southern antebellum novel with vitality.
Thesis78b.A347.pdf
2.56 MB
Adobe PDF
5e94c586cf9824b6493075a043f6d9ea