Writing style and lawyers' opinions of prejudicial news reporting
This study explored the feasibility of examining through empirical means possible relationships between writing style and judgements deeming pre-trial newspaper stories to be prejudicial. First, the literature was reviewed for criticism of pre-trial newspaper reporting that focused on the use of writing style. Next, the literature was reviewed for empirical methods available for the analysis of writing style. Finally, a pilot study was carried out to test the usefulness of stylistic analysis as a tool for investigating relationships between writing style and judgments of prejudicial, pre-trial newspaper reporting.
The review of criticisms covered books and articles by lawyers, members of the media, and communications scholars, as well as judges' decisions in major court cases involving the influence of newspaper publicity. The review indicated that while specific objections are most often related to content (the facts included in the story), there is also concern for the style used (the manner in which the facts are presented). Many of the critics seem to be aware that the same set of facts can be presented in many different ways, and apparently believe that some manners of presentation are more of a threat to a fair trial than others.
It appears that research into the issue of pre-trial news reporting has placed little emphasis on use of writing style as a possible variable. However, a review of studies from various disciplines involving problems with style suggested that there are empirical methods of analyzing style available to the communications researcher who is interested in investigating style as a variable. In particular, social scientists, utilizing available means of objectively measuring characteristics of style, have devised a technique of seeking out relationships between a dimension and the writing style involved. This technique, called by some an analytic stylistic analysis, has been used to explore relationships between style and such dimensions as reading ease, sensationalism, and human interest. In short, this form of stylistic analysis calls for statistical tests of correlation between selected, objectively-measured characteristics of style and what is called a judgmental measure--a measure that identifies the degree of the presence or absence of the dimension.
To test the feasibility of applying this method of stylistic analysis to investigate the role of style in judgments of prejudicial publicity, a pilot study was carried out. Six news stories were selected from a newspaper's coverage of a widely-publicized murder case. The stories were subjected to nine quantitative measurements of style: degree of modification, average internal punctuation per sentence, sentence and word length (Flesch Reading Ease formula), the average number of syllables per l0o words, the average variance in modification from sentence to sentence, the size of the vocabulary, and the number of personal nouns and pronouns per story (Flesch Human Interest Formula), the Sendex (a multivariate correlate measure of sensationalism), and the HQdex (a multivariate correlate measure of human interest).
The measurements of style were then matched against a judgmental measure--the opinions of an expert panel of trial lawyers concerning the prejudicial potential they perceived each story had for a prospective juror. The application of Spearman's coefficient of rank correlation produced earlier hypothesized positive correlations between the prejudicial ratings and eight of the nine characteristics of style. While the nature of the sample prevented the establishment of any significance levels for the correlations, characteristics correlating the strongest with the prejudicial ratings were the average internal punctuation per sentence and variance in modification from sentence to sentence. Stories with higher prejudicial ratings tended also to have less internal punctuation per sentence and less variance in modification from sentence to sentence.
The results of the reviews and pilot study presented in this paper indicate that investigation into the role of style in judgments of prejudicial news reporting need not be limited to subjective reasoning. Such investigation can be based solidly on empirical techniques.
Thesis78.T538.pdf
2.25 MB
Adobe PDF
33bb7bd2d7d718ff35bfc614a113ec4e