Judge expectancy effects and fair trial rights in criminal jury trials : an experimenter expectancy/judge expectancy analogy
Trial lawyers in criminal trials have long suspected that the nonverbal behavior of judges affected juror decision making. The purpose of this study was to present a theoretical explanation of judge nonverbal behavior and its effect on fair trial guarantees. The present legal approach to nonverbal judge behavior could then be examined in light of the theoretical explanation.
The theoretical explanation of the effects of judge nonverbal behavior was generated by using an experimenter expectancy/judge expectancy analogy. Social scientists have long been aware of the potential of experimenter nonverbal behavior to bias experimental subjects. A long series of experiments has established that, in certain situations, experimenters can alter the results of social science experiments by means of subtle nonverbal expectancy cues. The results of the social science experiments were reasoned by means of an analogy to apply to jury trials and the relationship between judge and juror.
The results of the study indicated that when there is an ambiguous juror task, the judge appears professional and businesslike, and the judge uses both auditory and visual channels of communication, an expectancy effect is likely to occur. In light of the analogy, present legal remedies for judge nonverbal behavior were found to be inadequate. New remedies including process instructions, instructions given by third persons, and juror training were suggested as a means to reduce possible nonverbal expectancy effects.
The legal community seems to be somewhat confused about the effects of nonverbal judge behavior. It is hoped that this thesis will be a first step in establishing a theoretical explanation of judge nonverbal behavior that can eventually be applied to protect fundamental fair trial rights.
Thesis78.S326.pdf
4.79 MB
Adobe PDF
8a1defe71e8fc55704f5a834e922468f