An experimental study of frost and ice formation in a permafrost protection device
The problem under investigation is the summer performance of an arctic permafrost protection device, the air convection pile. The air convection pile is a passive refrigeration device that convectively freezes and subcools the surrounding permafrost during the winter by air exchange with the cold arctic environment. This air exchange is accomplished by a tube within a tube device. The outer tube is closed at the bottom and is embedded in permafrost. The inner tube is shorter than the outer tube and concentrically mounted such that a flow path exists between the tubes at the lower end. In the winter, the outer tube, being embedded in permafrost which is warmer than the above-ground ambient temperature, convectively heats the air in the annulus existing between the inner and outer tubes. J The inner tube brings in the cold ambient air to be heated in the annulus. In the summer, the air convection pile should remain inactive, but ice and frost formed on the inner pile surfaces during the summer could close the flow path and limit or prevent winter operation of the piling.
This research was a preliminary experimental study with the goal of establishing the nature and severity of the ice and frost problem. To facilitate this study, a model air convection pile, an environmental chamber, a control system to cycle the chamber through day-night sequences, a humidity sensor, humidifiers, and an ice mapping device were designed and constructed. After the equipment was assembled, a l0-day test was run during which time ice profiles and photographs of ice and frost were taken.
The ice profiles established excessive ice accumulation in the annulus as the criteria which would prevent winter operation of the pile. To evaluate the data, two failure modes were established. The first failure mode considered the flow path becoming blocked at the top of the pile through ice thickness bridging the annulus. This failure resulted in the data being evaluated for maximum thickness. The second failure mode considered a situation in which the outer tube accumulates frost and ice during spring and early summer and then, as summer progressed and the permafrost thaw depth increased, thawed releasing the ice which drops to the bottom of the pile. If the mass of ice bridged the gap at the lower end of the pile, the flow path would be blocked and winter operation would not begin. This failure resulted in the profiles being used to generate a solid of revolution which was integrated to obtain the total ice volume. These ice volumes were compared to how much volume was necessary to close the pile to predict time to failure.
The air convection pile is for a number of reasons an attractive alternative to the permafrost protection device currently in use-the heat pipe. Unfortunately, this first experiment has shown ice accumulation to be a serious problem in the pile during summer operation. Ice accumulation could fail the pile in either of the two modes in approximately a month. Frost accumulation has not been found to be a serious problem.
Future studies will investigate possible solutions to the icing problem. Some possible solutions are to drain the moisture from the pile before it can freeze and allowing the ice to form in a prescribed manner that leaves the pile open for winter operation during which time sublimation should clear the ice.
I
Thesis78.O575.pdf
3.3 MB
Adobe PDF
3116142a3cb4a5956589733fb41f0b1b