The effect of art training on the Bender Motor Gestalt Test
Diagnosticians and researchers in the area of psychological assessment agree that the Bender-Gestalt Test is a popular and widely used instrument (Hutt, 1977; Koppitz, 1963; Schulberg and Tolor, 196l; Sundberg, l96l). The use of this test is based on the assumption that drawing ability does not have an effect on the results (Anastasi, 1968; Pascal and Suttell, 195l); however, little research is available to support this assumption. Therefore, it was the purpose of this study to observe the Bender-Gestalt Test score changes of students after they had received art training in basic art concepts. Forty-four second grade male and female students from one elementary school in Knox County, Tennessee, served as the subjects for this study. A pretest-posttest control group design was used to determine whether Bender-Gestalt Test scores would decrease (indicating improvement) as a result of art training. The experimental group, consisting of nineteen subjects, received the art training program for a period of two and one-half weeks totaling five and one-half hours of treatment. The control group, made up of twenty-five subjects, performed the regular classroom coloring activities during the treatment period.
Observation tables and a series of t Tests were used to analyze the results. F Tests conducted to support the assumption of homogeneous variances between groups prior to the t Test calculations indicated no significant difference at the .05 level of significance. The major findings of this research indicated that a significant difference occurred between the premeasure and postmeasure administrations of the Bender-Gestalt Test for the experimental group at the .05 level of significance. No significant difference was found for the control group on this measure or between the experimental and control groups with respect to the premeasure scores at the .05 level of significance. Further data analysis was conducted to determine if significant differences existed between the premeasure and postmeasure test administrations with respect to the number of occurrences of each of the four error types described by Koppitz (1963)--distortion, integration, preseveration, and rotation, respectively. No significant differences were found at the .05 level of significance for any of the four error categories for either the experimental or control groups.
These results indicate that art training does have a significant generalized positive effect, that is, not significantly influencing one specific error type alone, on the scores received on the Bender-Gestalt Test. The present assumption, that art training has no effect on the results of the test, should be re-evaluated thus questioning the present interpretations and popular uses of the Bender-Gestalt Test in psychological assessment. Further research in this area is recommended.
Thesis78.M395.pdf
2.48 MB
Adobe PDF
655267fb644467e09451fde63533bf37