Repository logo
Log In(current)
  1. Home
  2. Colleges & Schools
  3. Graduate School
  4. Masters Theses
  5. Presumption : an examination of theoretical versus pragmatic usage in academic debate
Details

Presumption : an examination of theoretical versus pragmatic usage in academic debate

Date Issued
December 1978
Author(s)
Kidwell, Michael Eades.
Advisor(s)
A. Juodvalkis
Permanent URI
https://trace.tennessee.edu/handle/20.500.14382/55753
Abstract

While the study and practice of debate is an ancient art, there are still many areas of forensic concern which have to be explored and studied. One area of pressing concern is the manner in which judge-critics evaluate decision academic debates. While different critics view a debate differently, there are some common elements in all evaluative schemes. One such similarity is the concept of presumption-the notion that an affirmative team must prove that an affirmative "plan" or new system is sufficiently desirable to warrant consideration.

The current study uses primarily descriptive-subjective methodology to examine the various judging philosophies currently in use and the manner in which they implement the requirements of presumption. Following an evaluation of the historical development of presumption, this thesis examines the extant works which outline alternative presumptive formulations and evaluates each.

The final and primary section of this thesis attempts to explain differences between the actual use of presumption as a judging tool and the theoretical position accorded various definitions of the term in current forensic literature. For purposes of comparison, the literature is compared with judging philosophy statements submitted each year by judges at the National Debate Tournament. The study covers the years 1975-1977.

The conclusions of the study indicate that judges are moving toward a greater acceptance of the "systems analysis" or "cost-benefit" paradigm and away from the traditional view of judge as an evaluator of "stock issues." Unfortunately, as this trend increases so does the discrepancy between presumption in theory and presumption in fact. While theorists contend that "systems" presumption is a relatively weak argumentative concept, large numbers of new "systems" judges continue to apply presumptive concepts generated by the "stock issues" approach. The result is that those judges who should be the best informed are often lacking in their ability or desire to apply theoretical constructs in pragmatic situations.

Degree
Master of Arts
Major
Speech and Theatre
File(s)
Thumbnail Image
Name

Thesis78K454.pdf

Size

7.96 MB

Format

Adobe PDF

Checksum (MD5)

b0eeb1d6bac46a15197d3e9587ee2099


University Libraries

1015 Volunteer Boulevard
Knoxville, TN 37996
865-974-4351

Map & Directions
Donate to the Libraries
  • About
  • John C. Hodges Society
  • Speaking Volumes magazine
  • Outreach
  • Directory
  • Employment
  • Policies
  • Library Intranet
University of Tennessee power T logo

The University of Tennessee, Knoxville
Knoxville, Tennessee 37996
865-974-1000

Events
A-Z
Apply
Privacy
Map
Directory
Give to UT
Accessibility

Built with DSpace-CRIS software - Extension maintained and optimized by 4Science